You sent me this link but it still doesn’t address that a perceived truth isn’t the actual truth. This still operates on the assumption that all users will unify for one perceived truth. What would happen with figured like Nelson Mandela that was considered an enemy of the state and also a hero? Two very strong competing truths. How does it account for non-objective subjects like metaphysical topics? This idea seems to still break down when account for the subjectivity of truth.
Also why do you assume all people would participate? This sounds like an additional job and not even all Americans take just one day to vote.
To a few points you could have network states within the Index that have their own defined truth. I assume there would be broader agreement because reality exists independently of our interpretations of it. As to additional jobs Wikipedia exists based on the labor of a very small number of people relatively speaking. That would be my hope. If it worked well enough to be the best signal of trust then I would also hope people would use it.
However, seems like I won’t convince you on this one so we shall see how it works in practice when I get a chance to start building it out.
You sent me this link but it still doesn’t address that a perceived truth isn’t the actual truth. This still operates on the assumption that all users will unify for one perceived truth. What would happen with figured like Nelson Mandela that was considered an enemy of the state and also a hero? Two very strong competing truths. How does it account for non-objective subjects like metaphysical topics? This idea seems to still break down when account for the subjectivity of truth.
Also why do you assume all people would participate? This sounds like an additional job and not even all Americans take just one day to vote.
To a few points you could have network states within the Index that have their own defined truth. I assume there would be broader agreement because reality exists independently of our interpretations of it. As to additional jobs Wikipedia exists based on the labor of a very small number of people relatively speaking. That would be my hope. If it worked well enough to be the best signal of trust then I would also hope people would use it.
However, seems like I won’t convince you on this one so we shall see how it works in practice when I get a chance to start building it out.